The Complete Guide to Effective Employee Appraisals
Employee Appraisals
The traditional appraisal process proves to be red-tape for most managers and employees. But appraisals don’t have to be like teeth extraction without anesthesia! When done correctly, appraisals can inspire your workforce, build cooperation and drive professional development.
Read on to learn:
What employee appraisals are
The business advantages of appraisals
How to set meaningful goals
Strategies for making feedback effective
Things to not do during appraisals
Performance management in years to come
Join TPP+ Today
Premium content to boost your performance, wellbeing and life success.
What Are Employee Appraisals?
An employee appraisal or performance review is a focused discussion of an employee’s work and growth. Appraisals typically include:
An assessment of the employee’s outputs and achievements.
A conversation about improvement opportunities.
Establish goals for the upcoming review period
Providing feedback on strengths and areas of growth.
The process of identifying training needs.
Formal performance reviews are typically annual. But many organisations are moving to check-ins more regularly throughout the year.
Appraisals are a crucial aspect of performance management. When executed properly, they tie individual progress to business goals, enabling employees to play at their best.
The Business Benefits of Appraisals
Performance reviews become a chore for many managers. However, accepting them can also yield genuine benefits, such as:
Increased productivity. Appraisals provide clarity about expectations. Goals drive focus and effort.
Better talent decisions. They also provide useful information in regard to compensation, promotion, succession planning, and so on.
Higher engagement. Not only do employees want to wring every dollar they can out of their benefits, but they want to see their professional status evolve, as well. Devoting time to appraisals shows you care about their growth.
Retention. Leaders can retain top performers through development opportunities and feedback on their strengths.
Legal protection. Documentation guards against wrongful termination lawsuits
Feedback data. Aggregate appraisal data points to organisational blind spots to fill.
Appraisals are the time to set each employee’s role in line of strategic priorities for shaping the organisation. When done right, they set free productivity.
How to Set Meaningful Goals
At the core of an effective appraisal is the establishment of purposeful goals. Follow these best practices:
Make goals S.M.A.R.T. That is Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, and Time-bound. This focuses efforts.
Ensure goals are aligned with company vision. Give clarity by connecting the dots for employees. What big-picture goals do their goals foster?
Collaborate. Engage employees in setting goals. Listen to their input. Encourage two-way dialogue.
Think about development goals as well. List skills workers want to develop.
Check in on progress. Don't just set annual goals. Go through them quarterly or monthly. Adjust as needed.
Allow stretch goals. Make goals that are attainable but take the person slightly out of their comfort zone.
Focus on priorities. Limit to 3-5 top goals. Do not hit with a big list.
Best Practices for Delivering Feedback
Here are some rules to ensure these conversations are productive:
Make it two-way. Have employees self-evaluate first. Without judgment, listen to their input.
Focus on opportunities. Delivery of commentary as a means to reach full potential rather than purely criticism.
Provide examples. Select 2-3 concrete strengths and growth areas. Tie to goals.
Invite solutions. Solicit feedback from employees on how to strengthen weak points. Develop plans together.
Make it timely. Don’t save it for annual reviews. Give regular feedback.
Give a mix of praise and constructive criticism. But praise wins and stretches people to grow as well.
Set the tone. Exercise an open, curious, caring frame of mind. Give trust and rapport time to develop.
Collaborate on the next steps. Commit to specific things (training, check-ins, milestones)
Follow up. Track their progress. Adjust course as needed.
Common Appraisal Pitfalls to Avoid
Although appraisals are invaluable and usually incredibly useful, they go wrong if you make these mistakes:
Lack of trust. If the relationship is weak, employees won't be candid.
Insufficient preparation. Inefficient feedback collection results in vague assessments.
Recency bias. Allowing recent events to colour the entire review period distorts the overall picture.
Contrast bias. There is an unfair comparison between employees rather than a comparison based on personalised goals.
Leniency bias. Ratings inflated due to the discomfort of confronting difficult issues
Solutions bias. Forwarding to action plans before problems/feelings have been processed.
Stay self-aware. Course correct if you see these biases creeping in.
The Future of Performance Management
The old school yearly appraisal is a breed of the past. Good organisations are seeking better ways such as:
More continuous feedback. Regular quarterly or monthly check-ins instead of one big high-stakes review.
Goal tracking in real-time. This is the seamless use of technology to be apprised of progress toward the goal.
Emphasising development. Appraisals as growth-focused rather than top-down evaluation.
Peer feedback. Description of the implementation of employee input from co-workers.
Project-based assessment. Measurable deliverables and outputs as a basis for judging performance.
Public recognition. Recognising contributions in team meetings or on internal platforms.
Manager-less evaluations. Self-directed assessment or having cross-functional panels provide feedback.
Scoring less, conversing more. Making ratings secondary and having meaningful dialogue central.
The future of appraisals is more flexible, tailored, and immediate. Many of these innovations are made possible through technology.
Key Takeaways
When done well, employee appraisals are deeply potent in aligning your people to strategic goals and building top talent.
Deliver honest but gentle feedback. Do a constant conversation instead of an annual thing. Embrace different methods that align with your culture.
With the right attitudes and behaviours, you can use appraisals to release enormous performance, passion and potential in your people.
FAQs
How to get employees involved in the appraisal process?
Explain the benefits. Stop making it top-down; make it a two-way dialogue.
Have them self-assess first. Collaborate on goals. It does not teach how to leverage development to drive promotion. Act promptly on concerns.
Do managers rate teams or single people? What are the pros and cons?
Group assessments facilitate aggregate feedback and growth. Individual appraisals create competition among the team members. Often, both have value. Explore team performance metrics collectively and individual impact separately.
How should compensation managers use appraisal data? What are the key metrics?
Distribution of review ratings, forced rankings, and manager scoring trends. Look out for appraisal inflation. Analyse goal achievement. Compensation decisions centred on productivity and competencies.
What training do managers need on appraisals? What are key skills to develop?
Empathy, active listening, objectivity, constructive feedback, coaching, relationship building, biases, and goal-strategy alignment.
How can I ensure a consistent appraisal process across the organisation?
Create centralised training. Set guidelines and templates. Calibrating the sample assessment. Have HR review/approve. Compare departmental ratings distributions.
We have extensive experience helping people conquer performance and wellbeing issues. Read more about our work or browse other articles. Get in touch anytime.